Overall, how do you feel about Sheffield City Council applying civil enforcement measures?

Oppose

Are you responding as an individual or a business?

Individual

Which of the following modes of transport do you generally use at least once per week to get around?

• Bus

• Car

• On foot

To what extent do you support civil enforcement on Site 1: Queens Road (A61) and Bramall Lane?

Oppose

To what extent do you support civil enforcement on Site 2: Glossop Road and Upper Hanover Street?

Oppose

To what extent do you support civil enforcement on Site 3: Hoyle Street?

Oppose

Do you have any further comments about the proposal to apply for civil enforcement measures at the locations considered in this consultation?

I am uneasy about the proposals because: 1. There is a danger that these traffic offences will be seen as ‘downgraded’ if they are no longer criminal offences. Some drivers may be less concerned about breaking the rules if the do not risk a criminal conviction. 2. The Council will be obtaining increased power over people. 3. The Council will have considerable financial incentive to adopt a simple, automatic system that imposes penalties with minimum admin. You do not say how the Police currently identify offenders and what their policy is regarding prosecution. For the Council ANPR will no doubt be the enforcement method of choice. You claim that ANPR will only be introduced where ‘all other methods of deterrent’ have been tried. This is a very high bar. However, we are not told what those other methods are, nor how their success or failure is quantified, nor why ANPR will succeed where they have failed. These are complex junctions and an automatic penalty system will make no allowance for mitigating circumstances. Box junctions are especially tricky – a driver waiting legitimately in a box junction to turn right can very easily find their exit suddenly blocked by another vehicle cutting in front of them. Will the ANPR system simply generate an automatic penalty notice, or will there be someone making a judgement on the circumstances? 3. Will statistics be published regarding the success or otherwise of the new system (in terms of the listed objectives) for each location? Will additional locations be added before the outcomes from the first sites have been measured? What will you do if the new system is no more of a deterrent than the previous ones?

Overall, how do you feel about Sheffield City Council applying civil enforcement measures?

Strongly Support

Are you responding as an individual or a business?

Individual

Which of the following modes of transport do you generally use at least once per week to get around?

• Bicycle

• HGV or van

To what extent do you support civil enforcement on Site 1: Queens Road (A61) and Bramall Lane?

Strongly Support

To what extent do you support civil enforcement on Site 2: Glossop Road and Upper Hanover Street?

Strongly Support

To what extent do you support civil enforcement on Site 3: Hoyle Street?

Strongly Support

Overall, how do you feel about Sheffield City Council applying civil enforcement measures?

Oppose

Are you responding as an individual or a business?

Individual

Which of the following modes of transport do you generally use at least once per week to get around?

• Bus

• Bicycle

• Car

• Motorcycle

• On foot

To what extent do you support civil enforcement on Site 1: Queens Road (A61) and Bramall Lane?

Neutral/Don't Know

To what extent do you support civil enforcement on Site 2: Glossop Road and Upper Hanover Street?

Neutral

Is there anything else that you feel we should consider before deciding whether to apply civil enforcement measures at Glossop Road and Upper Hanover Street?

104 Banner Cross Road

To what extent do you support civil enforcement on Site 3: Hoyle Street?

Neutral

Is there anything else that you feel we should consider before deciding whether to apply civil enforcement measures at Hoyle Street?

Sheffield

Overall, how do you feel about Sheffield City Council applying civil enforcement measures?

Strongly Support

Are you responding as an individual or a business?

Individual

Which of the following modes of transport do you generally use at least once per week to get around?

• On foot

• Bus

To what extent do you support civil enforcement on Site 1: Queens Road (A61) and Bramall Lane?

Strongly Support

Is there anything else that you feel we should consider before deciding whether to apply civil enforcement measures at Queens Road (A61) and Bramall Lane?

Consider how the proposal can improve active travel routes through the area.

To what extent do you support civil enforcement on Site 2: Glossop Road and Upper Hanover Street?

Strongly Support

Is there anything else that you feel we should consider before deciding whether to apply civil enforcement measures at Glossop Road and Upper Hanover Street?

Consider how the proposal can improve active travel routes through the area.

To what extent do you support civil enforcement on Site 3: Hoyle Street?

Strongly Support

Is there anything else that you feel we should consider before deciding whether to apply civil enforcement measures at Hoyle Street?

Consider how the proposal can improve active travel routes through the area.

Do you have any further comments about the proposal to apply for civil enforcement measures at the locations considered in this consultation?

Please use these power and the enforcement of such measures strategically to improve the active transport and public transport infrastructure in the city

Overall, how do you feel about Sheffield City Council applying civil enforcement measures?

Strongly Support

Are you responding as an individual or a business?

Individual

Which of the following modes of transport do you generally use at least once per week to get around?

• Bicycle

• HGV or van

• On foot

To what extent do you support civil enforcement on Site 1: Queens Road (A61) and Bramall Lane?

Strongly Support

Is there anything else that you feel we should consider before deciding whether to apply civil enforcement measures at Queens Road (A61) and Bramall Lane?

No.

To what extent do you support civil enforcement on Site 2: Glossop Road and Upper Hanover Street?

Strongly Support

Is there anything else that you feel we should consider before deciding whether to apply civil enforcement measures at Glossop Road and Upper Hanover Street?

No

To what extent do you support civil enforcement on Site 3: Hoyle Street?

Strongly Support

Is there anything else that you feel we should consider before deciding whether to apply civil enforcement measures at Hoyle Street?

No

Do you have any further comments about the proposal to apply for civil enforcement measures at the locations considered in this consultation?

No